2008 Agile Adoption in GIS Survey - results

Chris Spagnuolo of Data Transfer Solutions has released the results of the 2008 Agile Adoption in GIS Survey. A brief discussion of the results, a detailed whitepaper, and a summary of the raw data are available at Chris Spagnuolo's GeoScrum.http://www.edats.com/

Well, the polls have closed, the results have been tallied, cross-tabulated and graphed for the Agile GIS Survey 2008 (and unlike the Democratic primary race here in the U.S., we have a conclusion). A complete whitepaper detailing the survey results and conclusions is available here. A summary of the survey results is available here. A version of the whitepaper has also been published by Directions Magazine on their website and is available here.

Overall the survey was a huge success. We gathered 347 responses from GIS professionals from 36 countries. Here are some of the highlights:

Of 347 respondents, 32% said their organization had adopted any agile practices, 68% said they had not. This compares to 69% of the mainstream development world that has adopted agile practices according to Scott Ambler's survey asking the same question in 2007.

image

But don't despair. There is good news. Although the general agile adoption rate is lower amongst GIS developers than mainstream developers, once they do adopt agile practices, they do so pretty much in the same fashion as everyone else does. And more good news, of the respondents who indicated that their organizations had adopted agile practices, 86% indicated that they have used agile on at least 2 projects. This means that agile practices are moving beyond the pilot stage for the GIS development teams that are doing agile.

Within the GIS development population, there are definite differences in how different practices are adopted based on organization size and organizational experience with agile practices.

Another key finding was related to coaching and training. The survey indicated that 49% of Expert teams (those who have run more than 20 agile projects) have received agile training as compared to 0% of Rookies (1 agile project), 8% of Learning Curve teams (2-5 agile projects), and 14% of Mature teams (5-20 agile projects). Agile coaching displayed a similar trend in that 29% of Experts have used agile coaches to help improve and accelerate their agile adoption while 0% of Rookies, 3% of Learning Curves, and 14% of Mature teams have done the same.

image

So, at the risk of writing too much here beyond highlights, download the whitepaper and the results summary and check it out for yourself. If you're interested in more detailed results that you can run your own analyses on, please contact me directly.

I would like to thank the following individuals and organizations for their promotion of the Agile GIS Survey: James Fee of Spatially Adjusted and Planet Geospatial , Adena Schutzberg of Directions Magazine, Hilary Perkins of URISA and DTS, Glenn Letham of The AnyGeo Blog, Ron Exler of the GeoFactor, and Agile Commons. I would also like thank Ryan Martens of Rally Software Development for independently reviewing and commenting on the results of this study.